Â鶹Éç

Â鶹Éç BLOGS - Betsan's Blog
« Previous | Main | Next »

Plane speaking

Betsan Powys | 13:08 UK time, Thursday, 14 April 2011

Is it a bird ... is it a plane ... is is a single seater plane or does it take passengers?

Labour launched their manifesto this morning at the International Centre for Aerospace Training. Metaphors are welcome, said the leader as he arrived, just as long as you steer clear of "crash and burn".

If you were to create a 'wordle' of Labour's manifesto - a visual representation of the words used, in other words what Labour say they're going to do - then I suspect the word "delivery" would be the biggest and boldest of all. This is, after all, as Carwyn Jones first made clear at the party's conference in Llandudno, the decade of delivery. After a decade of what exactly then I asked Mr Jones? Back came the answer first outlined to journalists on the eve of that speech in Llandudno. We're not knocking what the previous leader achieved. His reign was inevitably about establishing devolution and the Assembly.

Newsnight's Michael Crick was in Barry to ask how Labour had the temerity to ask Welsh voters for their support when education, health, the economy were all worse here than in England. I paraphrase but you get his drift.

Carwyn Jones went into smooth-yet-solid mode, one of the reasons most Labour supporters made him leader. One of his challengers and you know which one, was giving Mr Crick a red-hot 'looks could kill' stare and shaking her head vigorously. There had been challenges, said Mr Jones and where there were fresh challenges, Labour were offering fresh priorities. You can read Labour's pledges in full One key pledge is to establish a commission a la Holtham to look at Public Service delivery and to create a 'delivery unit' directly acountable to the First Minister.

Fresh priorities? Where? - say Plaid. Nothing on reforming Barnett, no detail on how Labour would deal with the huge funding challenges facing Wales. Plaid too claim they got first to the idea of creating a not-for-distributable-profit company to run trains in Wales as their own. Rubbish, say Labour. We thought of it, oh, back in October 2009. Any advances anyone?

And yes, there are some howlers in this manifesto too. Plaid misspelled 'illiteracy', the Lib Dems got "General Election" wrong. Labour? They've got their own party name wrong .. Llanfur Cymru ... on every other page of the Welsh version. These manifestoes have created jobs already, said Jonathan Deacon of Newport Business School on his visit to Manifesto Corner on Good Morning Wales earlier today. Jobs for proof readers and sub-editors.

So come on then, I asked Carwyn Jones, is that a single seater plane or not? He'd seen it coming a mile off. Oh it's a two seater he said. But you can fly it solo.


Comments

  • Comment number 1.

    Another manifesto and another dossier of platitudes from our political masters. I agree Labour have transformed education as they state on page 7 but not many people would boast of such transformation when you end up with falling standards. As with PC, nastY league tables are banished to be replaced with "aspirational targets" not that we should compare school with school of course! As for their previous standards "not being ambitious enough" as male education standards slip - well thats a priceless quote to stand proud alongside other worthies such as "as useful as an ashtray on a motorbike".
    Finally as all the elite seem to be offering independent commissions to review government policies, offer advice and point to best practice just what will the elected politicians do with all their spare time now all these quangos can be blamed (sorry delegated with implementation review procedures auditing stakeholder delivery).

  • Comment number 2.

    Before Tony Blair and the New Conservatives (oops- meant New Labour) were first elected to UK government they made a manifesto promise to give a referendum on proportional representation. I suspect Carwyn Jones is doing similar, working on the principle that most voters forget manifesto promises.

  • Comment number 3.

    The First Minister is clearly learning from a former Prime Minister who following his election in 1997,and found how difficult it was to "get things done",created his own "delivery department",however it did'nt work and the welsh one will produce the same result. Until the provision of public services are totally changed in wales with more power and responsibility being given to individual recipients of services then the current structures will continue to waste money,and provide poor results. The Labour Party was been in "power" in Westminster from 1997,and in Wales has been either solely,or major part of coalition since 1999 and by any objective analysis we are going backwards,even though we throw money at problems than almost anybody else in UK. We have in effect voted for the "second division",as we are afraid,or a large part of welsh society is to take more responsibility for our individiual lifestyles or provision of services. The "well off" are getting out of wwelsh NHS with proliferation of private practices,both within and without the NHS,however media never touch on this subject as it too sensitive for "you know who"".

  • Comment number 4.

    You could argue for 'smooth but solid' substitute the 'usual waffle'. Coming from outside the bubble Crick asked the sort of question anyone should ask from even a brief look at the statistics since the Assembly was established. Perhaps the First Minister could explain,for example, who took the policy decision which saw the gap between Wales and England with regard to university funding increase from £20 per student in 2000/01 to £900 in 2008/09. By 2009 the gap with Scotland had reached an incredible £2276 per student. All of this at a time when the UK Labour government was throwing money at the Assembly. It is therefore hardly surprising that Wales hasn't got a university in the world top 200 and that only 14.6% of Welsh university research is considered to be world class.

  • Comment number 5.

    .......said Mr Jones and where there were fresh challenges, Labour were offering fresh priorities.

    The only priority Jones and his cronies have is to con the Welsh electorate into giving failed AM' and failed Ministers another term in Office. A term that will see Wales fall further behind the rest of the UK but will keep our AM's in well paid and comfortable jobs

  • Comment number 6.

    Where did Plaid Cymru spell iliteracy wrong in their manifesto? I don't see it?

  • Comment number 7.

    the "International Centre for Aerospace Training" - isn't that where the True Wales air-borne pig was retired to? (you know - the one that never actually got off the ground).

  • Comment number 8.

    I'm beginning to get the feeling that all these manifestos have been produced in a place called 'Llareggub'.

Ìý

Â鶹Éç iD

Â鶹Éç navigation

Â鶹Éç © 2014 The Â鶹Éç is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.